This review was originally published on ciao.co.uk on 22/10/2006
It is a rare occasion I buy an album based on hype alone, as previous experience has taught me that they tend to be disappointing. But after the enjoyment I gained from the last album I bought that way, Sandi Thom’s “Smile…It Confuses People”, I thought I’d try another darling of the MySpace crowd. So I decided to give Lily Allen’s “Alright, Still” a shot, especially as it was on offer in various places and available for less than £5, which was handy as with a running time of 37 minutes, this is a very short album.
My expectations going into the album were very low. The singles I’d heard had been OK, but didn’t really move my world and I figured that, as is often the way, this would be as good as the album got. I’m not greatly enamoured of Lily Allen as a person, either, with her chav attitude and stories of a bad girl past and her foolish statement that she was going to celebrate her first number 1 single (with “Smile”) by taking drugs. She did later retract this comment and claim to be joking, but I’m not convinced. One thing in her favour, however, is that she is the daughter of Keith Allen, whose “Vindaloo” single was a masterpiece to a football fan like me.
The album opens with the jaunty reggae tones of number 1 single “Smile”. It’s more of a pop-reggae sound, a little like Paris Hilton’s “Stars Are Blind”, although with a darker tone to the lyrics and more of a pop influence. A lot of the lyrics are half-spoke, breaking into song only in the chorus, quite similar to The Streets. There’s an interesting contrast between the jaunty upbeat music and the story the lyrics tell and it’s a song that has grown on me with repeated listens, impressing me more now than it did on first listen, largely due to that contrast.
There’s another upbeat start with the jazzy piano intro to “Knock ‘Em Out”. It’s again half spoken and quite The Streets like and seems to sit half way between being a skit and being a song. Again, there is contrast between the lyrics and the music, but it’s not as good a track as the opener, seeming more like Allen’s just messing around for a laugh than trying to put a song together and it’s a lot less mature in outlook
Next up is second single, “LDN” which, for a song about London, opens with a Latin sort of beat and a brass intro that The Mavericks would kill for, with a slight ska backbeat to much of the song that makes it seem a little like a toned down version of the Notting Hill Carnival. Otherwise, it’s back to the tried and tested formula of a happy beat and a slightly dark and depressing lyric, telling us what Londoners already know – it can be a hard and depressing city, but still manages to be a great place to be.
Given the dark nature of the lyrics so far, you have to think that “Everything’s Just Wonderful” is a sarcastic title. But you’d never know from the intro, which sounds a little like lift music. But, as before and as expected, it’s a jaunty up-tempo pop tune and the title is meant to be ironic. It’s not a bad track, but the album is starting to get a little boring by this point, as although the music changes every time, there is a repetition here with the contrast between music and lyric that seemed unique in the first song already appearing to be a cliché.
It’s back to the reggae theme for “Not Big”, which is a warning for any ex-boyfriend of Lily Allen, or another attack at the same ex as “Smile”, which would explain the same tune. Apart from being a bloke and really not fancying being on the receiving end of something like this; it is quite a funny tune. Although the lyrics are Allen having a go at an ex, she’s clearly enjoying doing so.
“Friday Night” is the chav tune I feared from this album, being hugely confrontational in the lyrics, although with some amusing insults thrown in here and there. Again, though, it’s a jaunty up beat pop-ska tune with the same half talking, half sung Streets style vocals which, combined with the tune actually makes me think of a female version of Madness. Allen isn’t as good as Madness, but she’s got the same foot tapping pop-reggae feel going on.
“Shame For You” is again a shame for an ex-boyfriend. There’s another slightly jazzy piano backbeat going on, with a slight blues edge. It gives the music a slowed down tempo and a darker twist, which keeps it more in feeling with the lyrics again. There’s the same chav confrontation thing going on in many parts, though.
As if to prove that she doesn’t hate all her ex-boyfriends, or can still think of the good times, “Littlest Things” is the albums first real ballad type track. The intro reminds me very much of Cat Stevens’ “Wild World”, which would possibly be an appropriate influence for someone like Allen, before the song moves into a pop influenced piano ballad. Like many love songs, this is a story of a romance, but it’s certainly a modern chav romance and not the idea of romance many of us may have. It does show the softer side to chav culture that the news never focuses on, however, so it’s slightly valuable for that insight and it is quite a sweet song, really.
Sadly, that was unlikely to last and “Take What You Take” brings us back to the confrontational side of much of youth culture. This is the ultimate chav song, with the backing vocals in the bridge sounding like they were written and performed by Catherine Tate’s Lauren character. There’s again an upbeat backing, with a slight funk influenced pop song buried underneath those lyrics and the lyrical tone reminding me of Shampoo from the 1990s.
“Friend of Mine” has a slightly more down tempo reggae feel than many of the songs before and is possibly the strongest reggae influenced track; not quite to UB40 levels, but not too far away, really. Strangely, this is more of a song than many of the others, as there’s more singing involved than the Streets style half-talking, half singing that much of the album has been based around. Strangely, however, the down tempo music and the sweetness of the vocal makes this less effective, especially as it’s another song trying to get at someone, as it’s a little too saccharine to be a proper hate song.
The album ends with my favourite track, “Alfie”, which is apparently about Allen’s brother. The music is halfway between a circus background and Scaffold’s “Lily the Pink” and probably wouldn’t sound out of place in a Disney cartoon. Again, though, the lyrics are a lot darker and the constant insistence on rhyming lyrics does give the song a very immature feel, especially with the nursery rhyme style music. For all this, though, it’s seemingly designed to make you smile and it does that wonderfully well, as I can’t help but grin when I hear this one, particularly as a huge “Game of Thrones” fan, through which I have come to know Alfie Allen.
With the lyrics full of insults and reflecting the chav culture that many of those outside it have so far failed to understand, I should really hate this album the way I expected to in the first place. But I don’t and that confuses me. I think that Allen’s masterstroke is the combination of dark lyrics with a jaunty background, be it with ska and reggae as the musical influence as for around half of the album, or the many other musical styles she borrows from. This means that the listening experience is frequently an enjoyable one, as long as you don’t concentrate too much on what the lyrics are saying, even for someone like me.
Of course, if you are a chav, particularly a female one, this is the album for you. For perhaps the first time, an album is catering specifically to a sub-group of youth culture. You’ll most likely be able to track aspects of your own life through the lyrics, which I was delighted to say I couldn’t.
For me, this was never going to be a classic album, but I enjoyed it a lot more than I thought I would. I expected to be disgusted and horrified and to play the album once and never again. But it is surprisingly catchy and whilst I still can’t quite get comfortable with some of the lyrical content, musically it is quite an enjoyable album and I can see myself using this album as background listening for a while, as it’s quite unobtrusive if you’re not concentrating on the lyrics. Try as I might and as much as I’d like to, I can’t quite hate the album. It’s not great, but it is alright and if you can handle the lyrical content, worth a go for the prices it can be found for.