This review was originally published on ciao.co.uk on 09/01/2011
The trailers for “An Idiot Abroad” put me in something of a quandary. On the one hand, they made the program look very amusing and I like Karl Pilkington; he’s round, bald, grumpy and funny. A lot like me in fact, only funny. On the other hand, I have pretty much hated everything Ricky Gervais has ever done; “The Office” irritated me, “Extras” bored me and the episode of “The Simpsons” that he wrote and starred in was the worst episode of that show I’ve ever seen. Thank heavens for Sky+, which is a boon for the indecisive like me, meaning I did eventually get to see the show.
Every time you see some travel shows, you know that weeks of planning have gone into it and the presenter knows exactly what to expect. In “An Idiot Abroad”, a lot of planning has gone into it, but the presenter hasn’t been involved in this in any way. Stephen Merchant and Ricky Gervais have set up their supposed friend to see the Seven Wonders of the World, but they frequently add in side trips and activities for him that he wasn’t expecting at all and usually won’t enjoy. The whole point is to unsettle Pilkington for Gervais’ amusement. If the viewers enjoy it as well, so be it.
The series opens with Pilkington being sent to China to see the Great Wall of China. Even before he goes, it’s obvious he’s not looking forward to it. As soon as he lands in China, he’s way out of his comfort zone. He’s worried by the reactions of the people and how he’s going to make himself understood and his concern gets worse once he sees the food and the toilets. Fortunately, some of Karl’s wry asides regarding what he finds in China are very funny. His reaction to the radio in his room and the massage he first has were quite funny and his astute comments regarding the need for High Definition filming were clever as well as amusing. There was also a great moment involving a pin, a piece of glass and a balloon which ended up looking like about the only bit of genuine fun Karl had.
The lack of preparation he is able to do for what he finds becomes obvious quite early on in this show, when he gets a call from Stephen Merchant diverting him off course to see a fortune teller. This was to happen several times throughout the show and even more often through the series. As an opening episode, however, this was a great taster of the programme, amusing in parts, showing the format of what will happen throughout and how Karl will deal with them. This is usually pretty badly and with a grumpy attitude, but often in an entertaining way.
The second episode sends Karl to India to see the Taj Mahal. India was always going to be an eye opener for Karl, who had only left Europe once before and that was in the first episode. A couple of things happened early in this episode which, if typical, I knew would annoy me throughout the series. Firstly, Karl’s attitude towards someone who was trying to give him a place to stay for the evening seemed a little ungrateful. I realise that the situation was difficult for him, but he never attempted to put a brave face on things or even consider trying out a new experience or way of life. His reaction regarding his trainers being ruined just seemed like he was moaning and wasn’t funny at all. The second was when Gervais left a message for Karl telling him what he had been up to, which seemed to involve a first class flight from New York. This seemed unnecessarily cruel.
Fortunately, there were some aspects to this episode which salvaged it later on. Karl’s reaction to meeting the senior religious figures of the Babas was interesting as he seemed to be quite moved, as well as slightly alarmed and disgusted in turn. He also manages to find some of his more normal cynicism in one of the hotels, describing one part most artfully as an “en-suite shed”, which was one of the better lines. Sadly, repeating it to Gervais later on over the phone resulted in another of his maniacal cackles, which ruined the beauty of that line somewhat.
The third episode is to send Karl to see Petra in Jordan, but they decide to send him via Israel. His skewed way or looking at things is perfectly demonstrated by his reactions to seeing the Wailing Wall in Jerusalem. Nowhere else will you hear it mentioned as receiving junk mail or religious figures compared to Pac-Man. Karl also gets to take control for a brief moment in making a side trip to try out the Dead Sea, which is strangely one of the few parts of the show where genuine information is imparted, rather than just Karl’s skewed view of things.
The cruelty with which Gervais and Merchant treat Karl is perfectly shown in this episode. They set him up for some extreme situation training in Israel, and then make him ride across Jordan on the back of a camel and stay in a cave in Petra. Unfortunately this does mean that there is very little time to actually see and talk about the wonder of Petra itself, although watching a camel break down and be loaded on the back of a truck was quite funny. Karl also manages to get some form of revenge at the end of the show, enjoying his night in the cave and proving the point he made at the start of the show that Gervais disagreed with.
The fourth show takes Karl to Mexico to see the ancient Mayan settlement of Chichen Itza. As with the Petra episode, there is an awful lot going on before Karl even gets to see the wonder. There is a lot more physical exertion required in this episode, with him trying out Mexican wrestling, horse and bull riding and an Easter Sunday festival that involves running in abject terror from a cow loaded with fireworks. There are a few very funny parts in the show, particularly his ongoing quest to find some Mexican jumping beans and the opportunity to give some of his food to the Mexicans, instead of just having foreign foods thrust upon him.
As amusing as everything up to seeing the wonder was, there was again very little time at the wonder. Karl did try to go in with a slightly more positive attitude than he has had for most of the series thus far, but that didn’t last all that long. That said, he did quite enjoy the moments when he put his own music on and introduced a Mexican lizard to the joy of biscuits and when his partner called at possibly the worst moment to try and get the DVD player working.
Moving on to the second disc, the fifth episode takes Karl to Egypt to visit the Great Pyramids. Gervais evidently plans to make things as difficult on Karl as possible, which again hardly seems fair on someone he has made to suffer plenty already. Having seen what has gone so far, it was always likely that Karl would hate Egypt and with Gervais trying to make things even more difficult for him. He didn’t get on at all well with the traffic, the people hawking food, or the camel, but he was able to make amusing comments about all of them and his evening on a Nile cruise ended surprisingly well for him, as he attempted to ruin Gervais’ plans that he should have a bad time.
Karl’s first attempt at viewing the pyramids didn’t go well and he wasn’t overly impressed by the visit he did manage. Once again, however, Karl’s cynical and grumpy world view makes for some highly amusing observations, although I can’t imagine his description of a pyramid as “Jenga gone wrong” would attract tourism to the area. His third visit was even stranger and the realisation at the end of how badly Gervais had stitched him up on the hotel room, once again aided by a smug voicemail message from Gervais himself made me feel a little sorry for him.
In the sixth episode, Karl gets to go to Brazil where he sees the huge statue of Christ the Redeemer high on a hill outside Rio de Janeiro and gets to visit the famous Copacabana beach. Unfortunately, he’s reached Rio at carnival time, so the heat and the crowds were too much for him and he wasn’t happy pretty much from the point he landed. That said, this did result in one of the more visually stunning episodes, even if Karl was possibly wishing that his outfit for the carnival wasn’t going to be on show in high definition.
Once again, there were some very funny moments, especially with Karl’s new friend, who invited him to stay and then showed him what he did for a living. Karl was also put into a number of situations that made him uncomfortable, both physically and emotionally, with a visit to a gay beach and getting waxed. At the end, Karl did have the last laugh, as a helicopter trip around the Christ the Redeemer statue gave him one of his most enjoyable experiences of the series and his report of this to Stephen Merchant really annoyed the latter as they clearly never planned that he would have fun.
The final trip takes Karl to Peru to see the Inca site of Machu Picchu and he did at least try to go forwards with a slightly more positive attitude, it being his last trip. He was even looking forward to a long trek through the forest and camping out. His one concern was the toilet facilities and he came up with an amusing and ingenious solution for that. As you might expect, however, this positive feeling doesn’t last long and he doesn’t enjoy the camping at all, although his obvious distress is one of the more real moments in the series.
Karl is also slightly unnerved when he hears he’ll be spending time with a tribe of former cannibals. However, the trip turns out to have some amusing moments despite, or possibly even because of, Karl’s worry that he’s going to end up in a cooking pot. The long trek to the wonder isn’t quite so good as Karl doesn’t enjoy that and it’s back to him moaning rather than being funny, although how he ends the trip in television terms is pretty amusing.
The final show is a welcome home, which is just highlights of the show with Karl talking it through with Ricky and Stephen. Much like the preview show, this is simply used to take the mickey out of Karl. Once again, Ricky’s insane cackling ruins much of the show. Karl is at his funniest here as he’s more relaxed and back in his comfort zone and it’s just a shame Gervais had to ruin it by being smug when he scores a point off Karl in the battle of wits and cackling wildly when he doesn’t. Sadly, when Karl tries to make a serious point about how he feels when other people react to how Gervais treats him, Gervais just brushes it off as a joke.
The extra on the first disc of this 2 disc set is simply a 22 minute preview show, which is pretty much just a glorified trailer. It would have been the perfect opportunity to sell the series, but is unfortunately mostly Ricky Gervais getting to take the mickey out of Karl Pilkington. What both worried and annoyed me the most is that Gervais spent large amounts of this show cackling like a witch. Admittedly, Pilkington had usually said something amusing when this occurred, but the end result was that it was like watching a TV show that had a very badly recorded and very obtrusive laughter track. I think it had the potential to be a fairly decent preview of the series, had it not been hijacked by Gervais.
On the second disc, there is nothing extra other than some deleted scenes. There are only 8 of these and they’re generally really funny, usually more so than what ended up in the show. Generally these are pieces where Karl gets to cast a wry and cynical eye over the situations he’s in naturally, rather than simply moaning about the situation. It feels as if these scenes have deliberately been cut out so the viewer doesn’t think of Karl as the funniest person on the show, even though it’s obvious he has more natural humour than either Merchant or Gervais, who are only funny when they’re picking on Karl, which is a kind of cruel and sadistic humour I don’t enjoy.
Given how popular the “Grumpy Old Men” show on BBC 2 has become, spawning books as well as several series of the show being aired, the basic idea behind “An Idiot Abroad” was a good one. Take a grumpy old man out of his comfort zone and leave him off balance and that result could be comedy genius. Unfortunately, his handlers were in the show purely for what would amuse them rather than what could possibly amuse the greatest number of people. The deleted scenes prove the comedy potential of the show, but the editing makes Karl seem more like a moaner than the funny grumpy person he can actually be.
As I have often felt about Gervais, he’s simply playing to his own ego and what may please other people is largely irrelevant. He’s treated this show exactly the same way and taken the edge off what could have been a really good show. If it had been allowed to be what it had the potential to be, “An Idiot Abroad” could have been something worth watching over and over again. As it is, this is really only worth watching the once.