This review was originally posted on ciao.co.uk on 03/06/2012
When Keane first hit the scene nearly a decade ago, they were famed for being the band without guitars. I was initially sceptical, with the rock fan in me not believing that anything good to happen without guitars. But sheer musicianship won me over and, given that their debut “Hopes & Fears” was the second best selling album in the UK in 2004 and won the Best Album Brit Award in 2005, I clearly wasn’t alone.
Since then, Keane have followed a more traditional path through the music industry. They’ve had a member in rehab, they’ve changed a band member and they’ve had an album which was a departure from their usual sound. They’ve managed to retain their fan base throughout everything, with “Strangeland” being their fifth consecutive Number 1 album in the UK charts, something even bands like Oasis never achieved.
The album opens with the jaunty synthesiser line to “You Are Young”, which gives the song a pop feel and reminds me of the quieter moments in 1980s period U2. Once the piano comes in, the song expands into something quite anthemic and the U2 comparison remains, even down to the “Woah…” lyric towards the end of the song. As I vastly prefer U2’s older output to their more recent songs, this isn’t a bad way to start as far as I’m concerned.
Next up is “Silenced By the Night”, which again has a jaunty beat which helps to move the song along quite nicely. This tracks doesn’t quite have quite the same pop edge and reminds me a little of Snow Patrol or early Killers songs. Part way through it does descend into a strange break, which did disrupt the flow of the song and my enjoyment of it slightly.
The third track, “Disconnected” has a slightly gentle opening that reminds me a little of The Beatles in places, such is the vocal delivery. Once the chorus kicks in, however, the song gets more of a heavy pop feel and it feels a little more like an Orson song. I quite like Orson, so this isn’t a problem for me, but there is again a slower middle eight that disrupts the flow a little.
After quite an upbeat start to the album, it’s a slight disappointment that “Watch How You Go” doesn’t just sound like the kind of thing my mother would say, but also turns out to be the kind of thing she might listen to. This is a piano led ballad that, thanks to the vocal delivery, sounds a little like some of Paul McCartney’s solo work, thanks to the pop ballad feel. It’s a decently put together track, but it’s a little bland, especially compared to what has come before. Still, at least this time there’s no awkward middle eight to disrupt the rhythm of the song, although maybe this time it would have been more welcome.
Fortunately, we’re back to the upbeat tracks for “Sovereign Light Cafe”. There’s a decent beat to the song, driven along by the drums, but the synthesiser adds to this and it’s a well rounded heavy pop song that bounces along quite happily. It’s a decent track and possibly one of my favourites on the album, at least up until this point.
“On the Road” is another upbeat song, with a driving drumbeat behind it. This one has the anthemic heavy pop feel of 1980s U2 or Simple Minds, particularly as the vocals do evoke Jim Kerr’s, especially during the verses. There’s a big sing along chorus that really cements that feeling into place. As I’m very much a child of the 80s, at least in musical terms, this is definitely a good thing as far as I’m concerned.
There’s an interesting intro to “The Starting Line” before it changes tone slightly and has the piano led ballad feel of “Watch How You Go” return. However, this time around, when the chorus kicks in, it expands musically and turns into something far more impressive than that earlier track, getting some of the stadium ballad feel that you can imagine a whole crowd waving lighters aloft along to. Although it’s another pop ballad, it’s certainly a vast improvement on the previous effort.
The synthesiser and what sounds like a programmed rather than live drumbeat open “Black Rain”. It’s quite a downbeat track, much darker in tone to anything that has come before and whilst it’s got that about it to help it stand out, unfortunately there just isn’t enough about the track as a whole to make it anything other than somewhat bland. It’s a dark pop ballad with a falsetto vocal that just seems to shuffle its way past you all the way to an unmemorable end.
There’s another interesting synthesiser opening to “Neon River”, but the opening verse is strangely dark and disappointing after that. Fortunately, as the song gets going, things do liven up a little and it soon develops into the kind of stadium heavy pop that, not for the first time on the album, evokes 1980s U2. The longer the song goes, the more this feeling takes root, as it adds a few more layers and a little more depth and by the end of what is the album’s longest track, especially during the musical break about 3 minutes in, I can picture Bono’s “Joshua Tree” era mullet standing at the microphone singing this one. How you feel about this song is more about how you feel about U2 than how you feel about Keane, but fortunately I was and remain a fan of U2’s older work.
By contrast, “Day Will Come” is a little all over the place. It starts with a synthesiser that New Order might have been proud of, before developing a U2 style drum beat and then having a more indie-pop vocal reminiscent one again of the Killers. Once the song does finally settle down to its final anthemic feel, it turns out to be an upbeat and enjoyable track and certainly sticks out as being one of the more exciting tracks on the album. Potentially thanks to it being the shortest song on the album, it is one of the few tracks here that seems to be over too soon.
“In Your Own Time” has an interesting synthesiser beat to it, but this is overlaid by nothing especially interesting, which feels like a bit of a waste. It’s a pleasant enough song, but it drifts by with little to stand out and whilst it’s a decent enough pop song, there’s little that you can grab onto it with and it drifts harmlessly by, albeit fairly quickly thanks to its up-tempo nature.
In ending the album, “The Fog” eases things out quite nicely, but sadly it’s another piano based ballad and whilst it does have an eerie sound and a nicely downbeat feel in the chorus, I can’t help but want to sing McCartney’s “Mull of Kintyre” over the intro and the opening verse, which for me completely ruins any ambience Keane were trying to put onto the song.
“Strangeland” isn’t a particularly bad album by any means, but it is a little bland and, following on from the departure from Keane’s norm that was “Perfect Symmetry”, it feels like something of a backward step. If your favourite Keane album was “Hopes & Fears”, then you’re more likely to get something out of this than if you enjoyed “Perfect Symmetry” much more. Of course, if you never liked Keane at all or, for that matter, 1980s era U2, this album will do little to change your mind.