Whereas Thunder’s “Live at RAK Studio 1” was a sanitised studio version of a live recording, featuring songs that were planned for the, at that stage upcoming “Wonder Days” album and cover versions for the intended live tour, “Live at the Brooklyn Bowl” was a proper live show. As it happened, there wouldn’t be much support for the album due to health issues in the band, which is reflected in the change of personnel here, so this was one of relatively few actual live shows and was much more in keeping with the setlist you would expect to see at a Thunder show.
This is immediately proved by the opening track, “Backstreet Symphony”, which is greeted with the enthusiasm you would expect for a 25-year-old classic track, both from the start and when Danny asks the crowd to sing along. As you would expect from a live show, the mix is a little fuzzy and the balance between music and vocals isn’t quite right, although I’ve heard far worse than this on live recordings elsewhere.
A bit of classic banter between Danny and the crowd opens “The Thing I Want”, which was a new track at the time. The crowd response is a little less obvious for a new song they won’t have heard before, but despite sounding a little like “The Life of Riley” in parts, it’s an up-tempo pop-rock track in Thunder style and you can hear a little of the receptions it’s getting as the song progresses and at the end and the mix is a little better this time around, if still a touch quiet and fuzzy.
Having seen the reaction and being here for the new songs, there is a bit of encouragement for the crowd before leading into “Black Water”. The crowd may not know the song, but they know Thunder and Danny’s banter has remained largely unchanged for years, so they know how to respond and what is expected of them. Although it doesn’t get the same response in the room, the mix is evening out and this is the best sounding song so far, as the darker tones to the music seem to suit the mix a little better.
In the opening to the previous track, Danny promised that we would get to some old songs and “Low Life in High Places” is definitely one of those and is greeted like an old friend and is performed by the crowd as much as it is the band. Both the band and the crowd come through nicely in the mix and this is a very clear recording, which is ideal for this song, as it’s ended the same way at live shows for many years and allows the crowd to be fully involved as well as to have some decent banter.
There’s an Andy Fraser cover up next, but “Be Good To Yourself” could have been a Thunder song or, going back even further, one of Terraplane’s. The jaunty blues groove fits perfectly with both Danny’s vocals and the band’s ethos, but the lack of recognition in the song is clear by a relatively muted crowd reaction at the end and the fuzzy mix which affects both music and vocals means the song isn’t as enjoyable on this recording as it should be given how good a song it is.
Next up is another song the crowd don’t recognise, with the title track to the upcoming “Wonder Days” album following straight behind. I remember this one as marking a slightly darker shift in Thunder’s sound and there’s another slightly muted reaction at the end of the song, which might have as much to do with a lack of recognition as an opinion.
There’s more familiarity with “The Devil Made Me Do It” and you can spot the recognition from the reaction to the earliest guitar notes. The sound takes some of the edge off the music and the backing vocals in particular here, but not from the enthusiasm. This is a song that has a call and response section that has been popular for years and it’s strange to feel that the crowd vocals come through slightly more clearly than the band in that section.
Another new song follows in “Resurrection Day”, although the muted cheers to the early guitar notes suggest a couple of people thought it was something else. Fortunately, the crowd is engaged enough that they will join in when asked to, even if they aren’t able to sing along to the whole song the way they have done on earlier tracks.
“Stand Up” is a longstanding favourite and it’s a song that has showcased the humour that often appears in Thunder’s lyrics more than anything else. It’s got a slightly rougher guitar tone in the main riff, so the slight muddiness in the mix isn’t quite as apparent, but when you get to the end of the song, the enjoyment that had been had in the crowd certainly was.
There’s not quite as much enthusiasm when “The Rocker” is announce as a Thin Lizzy cover and I didn’t feel from the studio version that this was an entirely fitting song for Thunder. It sounds a little better in the live version, which was probably the intended venue for the song anyway, but it’s still a little rough and choppy compared to Thunder’s usual smooth blues-rock style, but fortunately they just play the song through and move on fairly quickly.
The crowd reaction that greeted the opening bars of “Love Walked In” was the quickest and biggest so far, as you would expect for a song that had been part of the setlist for a quarter of a century. It feels that the entire room was singing the opening verse, as is usual at a Thunder show. Being an acoustic guitar for the opening verse, the balance of music and vocals seems a little off and even the electric guitar doesn’t quite feel quite right in the mix, but the crowd are in great voice throughout.
The crowd don’t need to be any more excited after that song, but Danny does a great job of working them up ahead of “Dirty Love”, which again is usual for a Thunder show. The balance in the mix has switched around a bit, as the music and Danny’s microphone are far higher in the mix than the crowd. This is a very long version of the song, but no-one has any objections to that, either in the band, in the crowd or listening in for the memories of so many great Thunder shows, with the only difference being the name of the guitarist being introduced.
After the fake ending, a cover of Creedence Clearwater Revival’s “Up Around the Bend” is first up for the encore and this is much more in keeping with Thunder’s sound than “The Rocker” was. Thanks to the recognisable guitar line, it gets a slightly better reaction than most of the other cover versions, although the clarity of the guitar notes in both the original and the studio version are lost a little in the sound quality of a live recording.
The album comes to an end on “Just Another Suicide”, which is recognised quite early on and is a perfect song to jump around to at the end of the show, although not the most obvious to sing along to. This time around it is the backing vocals which are treated particularly harshly in the mix, which is a shame as this is one of the songs where they have a bigger role than most.
There are 14 tracks and 80 minutes of classic Thunder banter and music in here and the only disappointments are what you always get with live shows and live recordings, in that the sound quality isn’t great and there are only room for a certain number of your favourite songs on the set list. This does have the slight advantage over the “Live at RAK Studio 1” album in that there is a lot more of the live energy and crowd banter than have always marked Thunder’s stage songs and it’s clearly a Thunder crowd, which makes it better than some recordings from larger shows and although some of the songs don’t quite hit either through choices or sound, this is a recording that brings back some memories, particularly as the next live show may be a while away.