I had enjoyed Ellie Goulding’s first few albums, but only as a casual fan, as I found that despite the pop ballads that had drawn me to her, that wasn’t her usual sound. On the albums, she has been more of a pop-dance singer, with the music too often overpowering the vocals and with a far too often generic sound that didn’t make her stand out. Unfortunately, these albums had made her stand out with the tabloid press, with tabloid media intrusion exacerbating an anxiety disorder that resulted in a long gaps between albums, until “Brightest Blue” was eventually released.
Appropriately, the album begins with “Start”, which opens with what sounds like a crowd noise, before segueing into a combination of piano ballad and club song. It’s a down tempo song, with a piano acting as musical backing for the most part and it allows the vocal to shine, which has happened too infrequently on Goulding’s work. There are a few production effects and added vocals to give the song a dance and r ‘n’ b feel, which takes a little away from the overall song, but it’s a decent opening.
There’s a gentle synth-pop opening to “Power”, which quickly adds a dance-pop beat that buries the vocals a little. It’s a harmless enough tune, but as it has a mid-tempo beat and a musical backing that often comes in over the vocals, it’s not one that ever really makes a mark, even with the chorus having an anthemic feel and standing slightly proud of the rest of the song. Like much of the work from Goulding’s earlier albums, it’s not one that makes her stand out as separate from many other pop-dance artists.
That’s the case again with “How Deep Is Too Deep”, although the beats here are a little darker and choppier, with made me think of Pentatonix in the early stages. When the vocals are allowed to shine, it’s a better track, as Goulding’s voice is a very good one, but they tend to be overpowered by the music on the chorus and there is too much intrusive production work and vocal and musical effects to allow this to happen as often as I would have liked.
“Cyan” is more of an interlude than a track, coming in at less than a minute. It’s a spoken word moment over a beat, but the voice is so over burdened with vocal effects, it’s not clear who the performer is. This leads into “Love I’m Given”, which has a choppy beat that reminds me a little of early Destiny’s Child, which doesn’t entirely suit Goulding’s sweet vocal, but there is another anthemic pop chorus that certainly does. The two parts don’t quite mesh together seamlessly, but this is a track that has its highlights, which can’t be said for some of the others.
There is a return of the piano ballad for “New Heights”, although the vocal has a fairly generic pop ballad sound, lacking the slightly accented delivery that makes Goulding’s vocal so distinctive. It’s a perfectly performed and note perfect rendition of a song that without the one elements that could have made this an Ellie Goulding song, could be anyone’s pop ballad, which is a shame, even as well-constructed as this is.
After seemingly losing her distinctiveness on the previous song, “Ode To Myself” seems an ironic choice of track next up. It opens with a guitar, which is also unusual, although the folk-pop ballad feel does again allow the vocal to lead the performance, which is something I’ve long felt Goulding should do more of and whilst this a short song at under 2 minutes, it is a beautiful moment.
The piano opening to “Woman” made me wonder briefly if this would be a John Lennon cover, but it is clearly an original song. The pauses in the vocal delivery seem to speak uncertainty, but it becomes stronger and more determined as it goes and the vocal sounds more like Goulding than the last couple of tracks. Everything about this track is gorgeous, with the vocal taking the lead over a gentle musical backing and it’s a moment you can let yourself get lost in.
After such a beautiful ballad, the heavily produced opening to “Tides” is not entirely welcome. This is a choppy, pop-dance song that relies more on effects and beats to be impressive than the vocals on the previous track. Even allowing for this not being my favourite style of music, this feels far too busy, as if everything that was stripped away to make the previous track so beautiful has been thrown at this one to make up for it and it feels as if there is too much going on here. This is followed by another interlude in “Wine Drunk”, which is clearly Goulding this time, but a synthesised version and this adds nothing to the album, even if it does sit beside the previous track fairly well with the over-production.
There is another rare guitar-based song in “Bleach” and it sounds like a female version of an Ed Sheeran song in overall sound, although the vocal effects and beats that come into the background take that comparison away a little. They also mean the song doesn’t have quite the same simple beauty as “Woman”, but it is another song that largely allows Goulding’s vocal to take charge for the most part, which is always a good thing.
That continues into “Flux”, which switches the guitar for a piano, but retains the down-tempo pop ballad feel. Indeed, there are moments here where Goulding does more with her vocal than I recall hearing over the course of all her albums. I’ve always loved her voice and on this song, as on “Woman”, it has been allowed to be the star of the show and this is one of the closest original songs I’ve heard from her that matches the simple beauty of the pop-ballad covers that first brought her to my attention.
The album ends on the title track, “Brightest Blue”, which opens with a brief Gospel-influenced moment, but then becomes a down-tempo r ‘n’ b sounding track. Again, there are a lot of beats and effects that get in the way of the vocal and although it has the vibe of wind-down time at a club, it’s not something I enjoy listening to in isolation, particularly when the vocals are again buried.
“Brightest Blue” is the most varied album that Goulding as released, with more piano ballads and occasional guitar-led pop songs in amongst the more generic pop-dance tracks. This means that across the 13 tracks and 42 minutes of music here, we get to hear more of her lush and beautiful vocals and less of the beats over the top, which is something I’ve been hoping for since her earliest work. There are some moments that don’t work and I can’t quite figure out the point of the interludes, but this is the strongest of her releases so far, in what it allows her to show.